Important Notice to Policyholders Regarding 2023 tax forms:

All 1099 documents for the 2023 tax year have been mailed to Everly Life customers as of January 22, 2024. Please allow 7-10 business days for United States Postal Service delivery. If you believe you should have received a tax form and have not (after allowing sufficient time for delivery) please contact our Customer Service team at 800.542.8711.

Welcome to Everly Life Insurance Company (Everly Life)

In 2022, the company formerly known as Settlers Life Insurance Company was acquired by Everly Holdings, LLC. As part of this acquisition, the company name changed to Everly Life Insurance Company. Everly Life is rated A- (Excellent) by AM Best Company.†

There are no changes to your policy number or the terms of your policy.

We are transitioning all correspondence, forms, and notices to show Everly Life Insurance Company, but you may continue to see information with the Settlers Life name until the transition is fully complete. Using the correct address is important to prevent delays in handling and processing of requests. Payments should always be sent to the address on the billing notices being mailed to you.

If you have any questions about your policy, please contact us.

Make a Payment

Make a Payment

Use the Everly Life Payment System for fast, easy payment processing.

Customer Support

Customer Support

View your account actions.

Contact Us

Contact Us

If you still have questions or concerns, get in touch with us.


All other mail for policy updates or request for service, including name, address or beneficiary changes should be sent to:

Everly Life
123 Town Square Place
PMB 748
Jersey City, NJ 07310

A.M. Best's 15 ratings are a measure of claims-paying ability and range from A++ (Superior) to F (in Liquidation). Ratings are current as of January 25, 2024 and subject to change at any time. While ratings can be objective indicators of an insurance company's financial strength and can provide a relative measure to help select among insurance companies, they are not guarantees of the future financial strength and/or claims-paying ability of a company and do not apply to any underlying variable portfolios. The insurance agency from which a policy is purchased, and any affiliates of those entities, make no representations regarding the quality of the analysis conducted by the rating agencies. The rating agencies are not affiliated with the above-mentioned entities, nor are these entities involved in any rating agency's analysis of the insurance companies.

CalendarBusiness Hours: Mon–Fri, 7:30am–4:30pm CT

© 2023 Everly Life Insurance Company (formerly Settlers Life)